I’ve always wanted to ask Doug Wilson…

Do you have a question that you’d like to ask Pastor Wilson? If so, we’d love to hear it. While we don’t anticipate being able to get to them all, we’ll grab selected questions each week and see what he has to say. The more your question asks for principals (rather than situation specific advice), the more helpful it will be to a broad audience and therefore the more likely we are to throw it at Doug.  So go ahead, ask by submitting a comment to this post (and feel free to leave the contact info blank – it is not required)…

 

796 Comments

  1. A. says:

    What should motivate someone to come to Christ? Can someone come to Christ because they want some earthly situation to be put right or does their motivation need to be eternal-minded?

  2. AJ says:

    What are your thoughts on AA and the 12-step addiction recovery program?

  3. Amanda Evans says:

    I actually have a question for Nancy… I’m wondering what the Bible has to say about placentophagy (encapsulated or otherwise). Here is a link to a blog post describing the benefits of it, but I just don’t know if the practice (leaving aside the ick factor!) is Biblical.

  4. Caleb Land says:

    What do you think about demonic possession and exorcism?

  5. Keith says:

    How do you personally approach Scripture memorization? Do you have a method you’d recommend?

  6. Paulette Murphy says:

    What is the biblical role of civil government? What books would you recommend on this topic?

  7. John says:

    Is the practice of “Lectio Divina” something that you would endorse? Should it be practiced in the Reformed Church? I have heard it characterized as, ”Hey, You got Buddhism in my Christianity!”, Hey you got Christianity in my Buddhism!” Two great faiths in one candy bar!

  8. Jason says:

    Enjoyed your series on academics and work. Would you suggest Christian Classical higher education for those young people who know that they want to learn a trade like carpentry or construction to prepare for their future vocation? Should they ideally study, if they capable of the work, at a Classical Christian College like NSA? What about young people who aren’t cut out for the academic rigors of this kind of higher education, how would you advise them to gain life formation during these crucial years between 18-22, if they aren’t capable of the kind of Christian higher education you are talking about. This should be a concern for parents and the church since if your estimates are right, this is 80% of our students ( since only 20% should go on to Christian higher education).

    I ask as a father of 5, some moving son into high school.

    Thank you

  9. Sarah says:

    Is there a good work out there that shows how the serpent’s lie of “autonomous free will” in the garden has affected all of society? I want to be able to better explain that “Arminian vs. Calvinist” should not be considered merely a second tier church debate that we’ll get to know who was right when we get to heaven.

  10. wesley says:

    How can I better articulate God’s trinitarian existence to my children? They are very inquisitive regarding this and I am unsure how to help them develop a category to understand this? Also, what materials would you suggest I read?

  11. Marcus says:

    Pastor Wilson,

    Can you give a brief history of the FV controversy for those of us who are just getting acclimated to the whole thing?

    Thank you!

  12. Marcus says:

    Pastor Wilson,

    If I am not mistaken, most Reformed Presbyterians would agree with John MacArthur’s teaching of “Lordship Salvation”. What similarities AND dissimilarities do you see between the FV expression of justification and MacArthur’s? Do you believe they are essentially saying the same thing (minus the covenantal emphasis)?

    Thank you!

  13. Chris says:

    What is the reformed view of hypnosis?

  14. Josh says:

    The Academics and Work videos were very interesting. Doug said in one part that he believed only about 20% of the population should go to college. I agree with this.

    However, if the vast majority of people do not attend college and want to work a trade, what happens when most of the manufacturing jobs in this country go overseas due to the cheap labor costs in China and throughout Asia. Is it wrong for the government to have a flat tariff on imports to make offshoring manufacturing jobs unprofitable? Would not such a tariff provide a larger supply of jobs domestically for those without college degrees?

    Most of America’s economic history before Woodrow Wilson involved high tariffs. We had more freedom then and no IRS. If not tariffs, then what? Does the government have any role at all in protecting manufacturing type jobs?

  15. Kai says:

    Chapter 19 of the WCF says that God gave Israel ceremonial laws, which consist “partly of worship, prefiguring Christ, his graces, actions, sufferings, and benefits; and partly holding forth divers instructions of moral duties.”

    What composes the former category is plain, but the latter is less clear.

    How are we to distinguish between these ‘instructions of moral duties’, and the ‘moral law’?

  16. Andrew Thorpe says:

    Dear Mr Wilson,
    Last Christmas our small group at church went carol singing in what we call in the UK a ‘multicultural area’ (significant number of Muslims). We had some bottles thrown at us by some local youths. We later received an apology from them and we were able to share the Gospel with them. This year our small group leader is reluctant to go Carol singing again as he says that it is “culturally inappropriate” and one of our other small group members thinks that Christmas Carols “don’t have much Gospel content in them anyway”. I think that this is a “public square” issue and have made this clear. I also think that Christmas is a great opportunity to witness in a manner which is different from “private” conversations (I am not against this form of witnessing). I am somewhat frustrated by this situation, but don’t want to irritate folk any more than is necessary. What would your advice be? I am pinching myself as I ask this question, but this is the UK in 2011 and one day it won’t be like this!
    With every blessing, and many thanks,
    Andrew Thorpe

  17. Jacob Hanby says:

    Pastor Wilson, I greatly appreciate and enjoy C.S. Lewis. I’d like to know how you work through some of his questionable theology (possible hints of universalism, ransom theory, etc.)

  18. Paulette Murphy says:

    Should churches and Christian individuals donate money to organizations that do good work, but do not also proclaim the Gospel?

  19. Andrew says:

    How literally should Christians read Romans 9:3? Is Paul’s desire in this verse supposed to be imitated by us today? Are we supposed to actually WANT to be damned for the sake of someone else, even though we know that God is powerful enough to save both of us? How can a faithful Christian actually WANT to be cut off from Christ?

  20. Andrew says:

    Can you give some real, down to earth examples of how Christians are to live in sacrificial love? I have heard the phrase tossed around a lot, but can you define it? What exactly does it look like? And what drives it?

  21. Wayne Scott says:

    OK. I know that you have talked about anglican/episcopal church before but I want to ask you this. I know that there is a rift between Lutheran and Reformed camps. What are your thoughts on the Lutheran expression of faith and how it relates for good or ill with the Reformed. The reason I ask is that there are no reformed churches in our area but there are several great conservative Lutheran churches. I would highly value your opinion on this matter if you so choose to address it.

  22. Katie says:

    I just read the book “Heaven Misplaced”. Learning about postmillenialism for the first time was mind bending — it altered the way I see everything. Being new to it, though, I’m wondering how to understand the time we’re currently in. Does the postmillenial perspective see it as a kind of “two steps forward, one step back”?

    • Mike Belknap says:

      If I may, a good analogy of the millennium is likening it to the process of genuine individual sanctification. We all have good days and bad days, hills and valleys, but the general trend is one of growing ever upwards.
      I hope you find this helpful!
      m

  23. JD says:

    Ive heard you mention before that you grew up as. Baptist and are now a Reformed Paedobaptist. I am a current ordained Baptist minister serving as a pastor of a Reformed Baptist church. I have also come to believe and accept the Reformed understanding of infant baptism, but I don’t really know what to do. Do you have any advice for considering a next step? I would love to serve in pastoral ministry in a reformed/Presbyterian church but do not know how to go about making a transition.

  24. Nathan says:

    Pastor Wilson,
    I have been listening to your and Joshua Appel’s discussions on academics and work, and with the recent popularity of Tim Tebow in the NFL, was wondering what you thought of a Christian man going into the field of professional sports? Should he? Can he morally? And, of course,what are your thoughts on Tim Tebow?

  25. DJ says:

    Dear Pastor Wilson,
    Does Proverbs 6:31 mean that if a thief is not found then he doesn’t have to voluntarily give himself up? What (if any) kinds of sin against your neighbor do not require restitution?

  26. Leah says:

    What is your response to these scientists that have supposedly created a virus that removes the “God gene” in people? Is that possible? Would God allow this to be successful? How should a Christian react to this type of scientific technology?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nADFJlAggnY&sns=fb

  27. Alex says:

    Do you believe in ghosts?

  28. AJ says:

    Drunkenness is clearly a sin. Is it also a disease?

  29. Bill Trip says:

    What did you think of the Rick Perry political ad on homosexuality that sparked so much backlash?

  30. Robert McGee says:

    Can adopted children be “children of the covenant” even if their biological parents are pagans? What about children raised by faithful grandparents?

  31. Anonymous says:

    Doug,
    Can you please comment on how Christians should view secular psychology in relation to advice for marriage, family relationships and raising of kids? If the presuppositions of secular psychologists are flawed, does this mean there is no common good/wisdom in what they teach? Or does common grace allow that they might have some wise things to say? How do we go about thinking this one through?
    Thanks.

  32. Michael says:

    Doug, I am forty years of age. I will begin my doctoral studies soon. Incidentally I feel as if I know nothing at all and am trying to play catch up with all that I should know but don’t. Is it too late for an “old guy” like myself to begin a self-directed study in classical education with the long term goal of establishing a school for the same purpose? What is the learning curb and where should I begin? Thank you for your time.

  33. Mark Williams says:

    What are your thoughts on the Christian Reconstructionist view of the law? Specifically as espoused by Rushdoony, Bahnsen, et al.

  34. Mac says:

    What is meant in Luke 21 and Romans 11 by the time of the gentiles.

  35. Mike Belknap says:

    In your book, ‘Future Men,’ you state that, “we must return to a world of vigorous singing, vibrant anthems, more songs where the tenor carries the melody, open fifths, and glory.”

    When I read this quote aloud to a musician friend of mine, she took offense at the “open fifths” comment. She said that this stemmed from the archaic idea that certain elements in song were “more holy” than others, and implied that Western music has moved-on “since the days of Gregorian chant.” She refused the idea that this has any relevance to masculinity. (This is, of course, simply my understanding of what she was talking about; indeed, I admittedly don’t even know what an open fifth is!)

    A response will be most helpful. Thanks!

  36. Justin says:

    If the church is to use discernment of false teachers such as Rob Bell, are we to do the same for political candidates? Isn’t misleading when Christians only look at a candidate’s salvation testimony and their abortion stance? They are not just asking for a vote from Christians; they’re asking to be followed.

  37. Josh says:

    What are some the distinctions between merely subscribing to “TULIP” and subscribing to Reformed theology?

  38. Robert McGee says:

    If for Christ’s death to be effectual for our salvation he was truly forsaken on the cross, what was the nature of his “forsakenness?” Was Christ separated from God in his death? Was he still God while he was forsaken? What implications does his “forsakenness” have for the Trinity?

  39. Robert McGee says:

    What makes the books which we call the Bible authoritative (as opposed to other texts)? Why are the texts in “the apocrypha” not considered authoritative? Who decided which were inspired by the Holy Spirit and when?

  40. Brent says:

    Is it irresponsible for me not to buy health insurance?

  41. Mary Moser says:

    Would like Doug Wilson to comment on the Driscolls’ book Real Marriage.

  42. Mary Moser says:

    would like Doug Wilson’s take on the Criscolls’ book Real Marriage.

  43. Caleb says:

    Is it a sin to have a vasectomy?

  44. Zac Martin says:

    I would love to hear Doug’s thoughts on whether he would conduct a wedding for unbelievers, and why or why not?

  45. Robert McGee says:

    Taking a post millenial perspective, what does it mean that there will be no marriage or giving in marriage in heaven? If everything is getting better, and if heaven is not like the Far Side cartoons, but the heavens and the earth will be recreated more gloriously so that even our cats and dogs and pigs will be recreated gloriously, why is there no marriage?

  46. Robert McGee says:

    What do you think of the “Catholics Come Home” commercials? Will they be effectual for anything? Will there be a set of “Calvinists Come Home” commercials anytime soon?

  47. John says:

    Hello,

    I was wondering if you could explain your understanding of 1 Timothy 2:15, the verse in which Paul discusses the salvation of women through childbearing, if they continue in faith, love, and holiness, with propriety?

    thanks,

  48. Josh says:

    What’s your view on Horror fiction?

  49. Positively Medieval says:

    The one guy that I believe truly encapsulates the book, Angels in the Architecture, is Martin Luther, which has lead me to explore the Lutheran church. What is your view on Lutheranism?

  50. Robert McGee says:

    Pastor Wilson, you have a large audience and great influence in the Church and aparently strong conviction regarding the need for another Church translated and printed Bible. Will you please initiate movement toward that goal and initiate the opening of an account for those of us who are unable to be otherwise involved in that endeavor to donate money? Even if the project is one that will take years, a lifetime, or generations, it seems to be one worth pursuing. It seems that before the Church can begin a long work of raising the great cathedral of scriptural translation, we must raise the money required. If no one else in the Church will begin the movement, can it begin in Moscow (which seems to be a center of academia and Christianity)? If not, where else should we look in the Church to begin this project?

Trackbacks

  1. Ask Doug: Intellectual Property — CanonWired
  2. Conversation: Was C.S. Lewis a Calvinist? — CanonWired
  3. Ask Doug: Young Men and Hubs for Homosexuality — CanonWired
  4. Advice for Newly Married Couples: Conversation between Doug Wilson and Toby Sumpter — CanonWired
  5. Toby Sumpter: How I Became a Pastor — CanonWired
  6. Dave Kraft on Leadership — CanonWired
  7. Conversation: What does it mean to be ‘Kuyperian’? — CanonWired
  8. The Clerical Collar: Conversation with Doug Wilson and Toby Sumpter — CanonWired
  9. Conversation: Which version of the Westminster Confession of Faith? — CanonWired
  10. Conversation: The Fellowship of the Grievance — CanonWired
  11. Ask Doug: Is it sinful to enjoy a cigar on occasion? — CanonWired
  12. Conversation: Protections for workers in a free market economy? — CanonWired
  13. Ask Doug: Secular Christmas Music — CanonWired
  14. Ask Doug: Helping Children Learn Finances — CanonWired
  15. Ask Doug: How do you know when to give your child communion? — CanonWired
  16. Ask Doug: Disciplining a Child in Public — CanonWired
  17. Ask Doug: Could Jesus Return Today? — CanonWired
  18. Ask Doug: Establishing Household Culture — CanonWired
  19. Ask Doug: Is it ok to Accumulate Wealth? — CanonWired
  20. Ask Doug: Women Working Outside of the Home — CanonWired
  21. Ask Doug: Contraceptives? — CanonWired
  22. Ask Doug: Leaving a Church — CanonWired
  23. Ask Doug: Is Baptism Necessary for Salvation? — CanonWired
  24. Ask Doug: Rebaptism — CanonWired
  25. Ask Doug: Is God’s Wrath Loving? — CanonWired
  26. Ask Doug: Role of Works in Justification and Future Justification — CanonWired
  27. Ask Doug: Why didn’t God save the whole world? — CanonWired
  28. Dave Kraft on his book, “Leaders Who Last” — CanonWired
  29. Ask Doug: Martial Arts for Girls — CanonWired
  30. Ask Doug: Radical Two Kingdom Theology and Luther — CanonWired
  31. Ask Doug: What is your position on tattoos? — CanonWired
  32. Ask Doug: Vocabulary of “LOL” — CanonWired
  33. Ask Doug: What did Francis Schaeffer mean by ‘Antithesis’? — CanonWired
  34. Doug Wilson on Thanksgiving and family relationships — CanonWired
  35. Ask Doug: Too Many Presents at Christmas? — CanonWired
  36. [re-post] Ask Doug: Christopher Hitchens and Cancer — CanonWired
  37. Ask Doug: Classical Education and Ancient Mythology — CanonWired
  38. Ask Doug: The Manhattan Declaration — CanonWired
  39. Ask Doug: Perseverance of the Saint and Reality of Apostasy — CanonWired

Leave a Comment